Bagua Map vs Personal Kua — Why the Two Charts Should Not Be Overlaid
People sometimes place two charts on the same home and find that they do not agree. One is a door-based bagua map: a set of life-area sectors often started from the entrance or front door. The other is a personal Kua direction table, calculated from a birth date. This page explains why those two charts can disagree, why they should not be overlaid, and what Sibyl actually computes.
Sibyl provides a Kua Number calculator. It does not provide a bagua map. What Eight Mansions Is explains the layer the calculator implements. The feng shui guide already contrasts personal Kua with Annual Flying Stars; this page is not that contrast.
Two charts, two inputs
A door-based bagua map takes the home — commonly the front door, or the way the plan is read from the entrance — as its starting point, then labels sectors of that plan with life areas. Those life-area names are not Sibyl's direction names, and this page does not teach how to place such a map.
A personal Kua table takes a birth date. On Sibyl, the Feng Shui year is set at Li Chun, not on 1 January, and the tradition's sex input is part of the formula. The result is a personal identity — a Kua number, an East or West Group, a trigram, and an element — plus eight named compass directions for that Kua. Hand steps stay on How to Calculate Your Kua Number.
Why they can disagree on the same home
Disagreement on the same floor is an expected result of those different inputs. It is not, by itself, evidence that one of the charts was calculated wrongly.
*Fictional example, not a real home and not a layout prescription.* Jordan has a Kua 1 result on Sibyl and lives in a flat whose front door is on the south wall. On the published Kua 1 table, east is a Favourable reference and west is a Caution reference — personal categories, not room commands, as explained on Eight Mansions direction names. A door-based bagua map, which Sibyl does not provide, might place a life-area label some of those maps call a “wealth” sector in the west room. “Wealth” is not an Eight Mansions direction name on Sibyl, and it is not another name for Sheng Qi · Growth.
Those two statements can both follow their own inputs and still disagree about the west room. That disagreement is expected. It does not turn the west room into a problem, or the east room into a place that must attract money.
They should not be overlaid
The two charts should not be merged into one picture that tries to follow a life-area sector and a personal Favourable reference at the same time. Overlaying them does not produce a more complete house reading; it produces mixed labels that no longer belong to a single method.
This page does not rank those methods, and it does not say which one is more accurate. A door-based placement practice is not a method Sibyl provides.
A personal Kua table should also not be merged with an Annual Flying Stars chart. The feng shui guide already keeps those two on separate levels; this page does not rewrite that contrast. A bagua map is not a substitute for either of them.
What Sibyl computes — a personal Kua table, not a house bagua map
The Kua Number calculator computes a personal table under Rule version 1.0.0: the Kua number, the Feng Shui year, an East or West Group, a trigram, an element, and eight direction labels. East Group and West Group are organizing labels — “labels, not luck scores” — not a ranking of people. The eight official names, and the product polarity Favourable reference / Caution reference, are on the direction names page. What the trigram, element, and Trigram direction are is on Kua trigrams.
The final displayed Kua is never 5. There is no Kua 5 row in the trigram table. When the arithmetic reaches 5, Sibyl applies a traditional substitution that differs by birth sex, and the result is one of the eight displayed Kua numbers. That step belongs on How to Calculate Your Kua Number; if a hand calculation lands on 5, finish on the calculator so the substitution matches Rule version 1.0.0.
The calculator does not take a house sitting or facing, a floor plan, or a door as an input. It does not output a bagua map or a grid of life-area sectors. Sibyl does not provide a bagua map tool.
The calculator already states the limit: “A personal Kua is not a property audit.”
What neither chart decides here
Neither a door-based bagua map nor a personal Kua table can decide a renovation, activate a “wealth” sector, fix a relationship corner, improve health, or give a reason to move house. Favourable reference is not a luck guarantee; Caution reference is not a curse or a “cure” list.
The eight personal direction names stay on Eight Mansions direction names. This page does not redefine them, and it does not treat Sheng Qi · Growth as a “wealth corner.”
Practical needs come first: light, air, access, structure, and comfort. Tradition, if used at all, stays secondary and non-prescriptive.
The feng shui guide keeps a third level separate: “Facing, construction period, floor plan, openings, and site conditions belong to a fuller building method that this product does not provide.” Neither chart on this page is that assessment.
Later-heaven direction vocabulary appears on the Lo Shu square page as a symbolic correspondence, not as a floor-plan property. Like the trigrams page, this page does not open a bagua encyclopedia.
Frequently asked questions
If my Kua “favourable” direction is east but a bagua map puts “wealth” in a west room, which should I use?
Do not overlay the two charts in order to pick a winner for that room. They have different inputs, and disagreement is expected. A Favourable reference is a personal category, not a command to use the east room for money. A “wealth” sector is a life-area label some bagua maps use, not an Eight Mansions direction name on this site. Neither chart is a house audit. Light, air, access, structure, and comfort come first.
Does Sibyl provide a bagua map?
No. Sibyl does not provide a bagua map tool. The Kua Number calculator produces a personal Kua table — not a door-based plan, and not a grid of life-area sectors.
Is a bagua map the same as Eight Mansions or Annual Flying Stars?
No. Eight Mansions, as Sibyl implements it, is a personal Kua and eight direction labels. Annual Flying Stars is a one-year, nine-palace overlay. A door-based bagua map is neither of those charts. The guide — whose heading is “Two tools for two different spatial questions” — contrasts Kua with the annual overlay; it is not a bagua-map guide.